I like Urban Decay Primer Potion for eye primer. I don't find a foundation primer necessary, but I think girls with oily skin would get the most benefit from it? Lashes: Ardells from the drugstore, with Duo glue. Liner: I sometimes use liquid, sometimes use gel. I think they're both great for a precise, dramatic, dark look. Revlon's liquid is nice and L'Oreal's HIP gel/cream liner is great. The factor that might help you decide is whether you prefer using a pen versus a brush. Eyeshadow: NYX (both palettes and loose pigments) and L'Oreal HIP. NARS's blush is great. You could also consider a cream blush, I use NYX's.