Discussion in 'Ballroom Dance' started by DanceMentor, Sep 19, 2013.
For me no one compares to Mirko and Edita
youtube [dot] /watch?v=oZ9dTQCh1Dw
youtube [dot] /watch?v=SB4Gntd6jwI
youtube [dot] /watch?v=rD-Ph2dv240
youtube [dot] /watch?v=pu3oK0suOoo
youtube [dot] /watch?v=Ywu9NU0yuqg
Sorry, wasn't trying to hijack
Maybe a new thread?
Back to our regularly scheduled programing...
A&K = Controlled, Calm.
V&A = Fevered, Toiled.
Thanks for the videos.
I am rooting for Victor and Anastasia to improve enough to win as soon as possible, but I have to say I find Arunas and Katusha vastly superior in these videos. For example Anastasia's head gets a bit loose at 0:41, and in general is imperfectly positioned, something that's not very noticeable until one looks at Katusha's perfect positioning, as well as her excellent head shaping, such as at 0:17 and 1:11.
In terms of movemennt, Victor and Anastasia tend to flight their tango more than do Arunas and Katusha, and I find their leg action less accurate; Arunas and Katusha do a better job of maintaining the staccato action associated with tango. When they get some open space, their better technique results in Arunas and Katusha having more grounded and powerful movement as well as better floor coverage, such as in the second long side starting at 1:15, though I grant that Victor is better at finding open space.
I guess I agree with this. No doubt A and K are incredibly clean- nearly perfect in their technique. But I do find them a bit boring to watch as well. From a spectator position, V and A are my favorites. I can see why a judge would pick A and K though.
I agree with this too, even though I'm not a huge fan of A&K. They are the best technically. But they seem sort of one dimensional in terms of emotions. I feel almost a cold feeling when I watch Katusha dance. At least V and A are more dynamic when it comes to opening up their emotions on the floor. I feel if A&K could up their game emotionally, they would be able to put that much more distance between them and the second place couple. Where as if V&A could be more refined in their technique, yet still very powerful emotionally, they could easily surpass A&K withholding politics, in my opinion.
this made me giggle
We all know it comes into play, as much as we hate it
Agreed. Aside from competition, I think it really shows in their showdances too. At Dance Legends a few years ago, V&A nearly brought me to tears with their Waltz, and their Tango made me laugh heartily (because the routine was intentionally funny, not because it was bad). When I watched A&K, it was a bit more ... underwhelming? though I appreciated how precise and technically-sound everything was.
I prefer Victor & Anastasia's performance quality and the thought they put into their showdances. Arunas and Katusha appear to be practically flawless and do seem technically better, but most of their showdances don't interest me very much - they seem very competition-routine-y with a few showdance elements thrown in. V & A just move me more, in general.
(This thread just makes me think of the other thread debate/discussion about various Latin couples, and it's all about what you value more/less in an "ideal" couple.)
I was just thinking the same thing...it reminds me of some of the debates about top rhythm couples as well....
As Tim Gunn from Project Runway would say, it's all a matter of taste
I found it very strange that Anastasia's right foot is more forward than Victor's left foot at their very first promenade position. Is it only me?
I recall a comp in San Fran where there was a show with Victor/Anastasia, Mirko/Edita, and Arunas/Katusha. I was fully expecting to like Mirko/Edita best, then it would be a toss up between the other two couples. Instead, I was blown away by Victor/Anastasia, and Mirko/Edita were sort of disappointing for me. Seeing them in person made a big difference. I don't know that you can always go by what you see in a video. And worth noting, it seemed obvious the crowd liked Victor/Anastasia better that night too. That said, a show is not the same as a competition.
I didn't notice that specifically until you mentioned it, but I wasn't thrilled with the link and subsequent walk. That said, Arunas and Katusha aren't perfect on that figure either. Both couples seem to cut short the step out of the link by different amounts.
When you think about the couple that would be more popular on television or to a spectator that didn't know a whole lot, I have to wonder how Arunas and Katusha would compare. There quality is absolutely marvelous, but is that the only thing to consider?
I remember sitting next to someone who didn't know a lot about ballroom dancing. They had watched a quarter, then a semi, and it was the final. They asked who I thought would win, and I said definitely Arunas and Katusha. They were like, "Oh, really? I never would have thought that!". I don't think that would be a unique situation.
I think it depends a lot on the spectator. Ultimately, though, competitions are about impressing knowledgeable judges; the place to impress spectators is in shows.
Yea, who needs spectators?
lol... organizers for one!!
Separate names with a comma.